Journalist reminds Apple of Newton flop, presuming iPhone will do the same
David Haskin at Computer World has written a fairly negative piece that is supposed to remind Apple of their Newton PDA and how it didn't do very well.
What does Apple's iPhone have in common with the failed Apple Newton of more than a decade ago? Nothing. Yet.
is the provocative start to the article.
He tells us what we already know. Apple don't have an 'unblemished record' when it comes to introducing innovative new devices. Sure, but by that logic, neither do a number of other successful companies. Few businesses have a 100% success rate, particularly when they are as innovative and boundary-pushiing as Apple.
Hoskin claims that the Newton failed partly due to its poor implementation of a new technology - handwriting recognition - but primarily because of its high price.
He then somehow draws the conclusion that "Apple seems to be repeating the cycle again with iPhone".
Aren't you forgetting something, David? The iPod. An absolutely phenomenal success that now has 80% of the portable music player market. You write as if Apple makes the same mistakes with every product it launches. It doesn't.
Apple's projections are to secure 1% of the global mobile market come 2008, a goal that independent analysts think is definitely achievable. The iPhone may not be a runaway, market-dominating success like the iPod is, just as Apple's computers aren't, but that doesn't mean the iPhone will flop.
Sure, there's hype and incredible excitement as we all wait for the iPhone, but there's also an incredibly hot, innovative product that other manufacturers are already taking serious note of. Would they take note of something that's destined to flop? I don't think so.
Related stories:
Powermat: Revolutionary Gadget Charging
Came straight to this page? Visit www.iphonic.tv for all the latest news.
About iphone e-mail:
iphone has great e-mail features, but will it really be usefull? Most of my e-mail are zipped, or office doc's, or files with .wmv or .wma extensions. Those are Windows extensions, supported by wm6 phones, but apple doesn't support those even on Mac Os X (we have to install flip4mac codecs so we can see those). I suppose we cannot install codecs on a phone, so how will we be abble to see mails on iphone? Only text mails? This would be very limited and unuseffull. It would be great to see a post about this, so people could discuss...
Posted by: Rui Jorge | February 28, 2007 8:23 PM